Menu of Curly's Pizza & Subs in Lima, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Curly’s Pizza & Subs, nestled in the East Gate Shopping Center of Lima, Ohio, offers a satisfying blend of classic pizza parlor charm and hearty subs that appeals to both families and casual diners alike. From the moment you walk in, the straightforward, no-frills atmosphere puts the spotlight squarely on what matters most here — the food. And that food does not disappoint.

Their menu highlights speak volumes about a place confident in its offerings. The Pepperoni Pizza stands out as a reliable favorite, boasting a generous layer of flavorful pepperoni atop a well-baked crust. For cheese lovers, the Cheese Sticks and Cheese Bread deliver that perfect melty, golden indulgence, ideal as an appetizer or a sharing snack. On the spicier side, the Jalapenos & Sausage Pizza provides a savory kick that balances heat and hearty sausage bits with a lush cheese blend.

Subs at Curly’s bring a whole other dimension of flavor. The Philly Steak Sub, loaded with mozzarella, onions, green peppers, mayo, and fresh lettuce, offers a classic experience that’s both rich and satisfying. Equally impressive is the Heatwave Sub, a fiery concoction of hot chicken and ranch that wakes up the palate without overwhelming it. For those craving traditional Italian-American flavors, the Meatball Sub hits the mark with tender meatballs, tangy sauce, and gooey mozzarella.

Perhaps one of the most exciting aspects at Curly’s is the option to Build Your Own, whether it’s a mega slice, a 10-inch gluten-free crust, or an 18-inch classic pizza. This customization means you’re never locked into a preset combination, letting creativity run wild while maintaining high-quality ingredients and balanced flavors.

The calzones and strombolis add a deliciously stuffed, oven-baked twist to the menu. The 10-inch BBQ Chicken Calzone wrapped with Sweet Baby Ray’s sauce, chicken, bacon, and mozzarella offers a smoky, creamy bite, while the Deluxe Stromboli loaded with pepperoni, sausage, beef, mushrooms, and peppers provides a robust medley of tastes and textures.

Customer feedback reinforces the strong points of Curly’s Pizza & Subs. Debbie Best praised the breadsticks and cheese bread, noting their satisfying flavors, even if the pizza didn’t quite top her personal list. Nick Kennedy highlighted both the subs and specialty pizzas as delicious and good value, making it a reliable spot for family dinners. Sarah Glover’s enthusiastic testimonials about the cheesy, well-topped pizzas and friendly, local family-run service underscore the community-driven feel of the restaurant. Positive reviews keep surfacing around both the subs and pizzas, confirming the consistent quality and inviting nature of the establishment.

In summary, Curly’s Pizza & Subs offers a compelling menu that balances tradition with customization and flavor-packed specials. Whether you are here for a quick, cheesy snack, a loaded sub, or a hearty meal to share, the quality and taste deliver well above expectations. A strong contender in Lima’s pizza scene, it deserves a spot on your list when craving down-to-earth, satisfying Italian-American fare.